Skip to Main Content

History: Book Reviews

Indexes to and Sources of Book Reviews

Using Book Reviews For Research

Book reviews are not considered research and are generally not used as evidence in a research paper. The purpose of book reviews is to compare and contrast an author's thesis with other scholars' ideas. This means that the book review does not present research, i.e. primary sources to construct a new argument. Book reviews are good for identifying works that you may not have known about, to clarify an author's argument that is unclear, and to summarize competing aguments.

How to Write a Book Review

Remember that a book review is not to detail the contents of a book, rather to give enough information about the work for the reader to understand your comments about the work. Some suggestions for the content of a book review:

  • What is the author's thesis and purpose?
  • Has the author's background affected his or her analysis? (quaifications/biography)
  • Who is the audience for the book?
  • Provide a BRIEF summary of the content.
  • What is the author's evidence?
  • How does this work fit into the existing research? Does it add any value?
  • What is your assessment of the  successes and failures of the author's research?